• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

Foskett Services

You are here: Home / Commentary / The Power of Negative Publicity

February 1, 2011 by Stephen Foskett

The Power of Negative Publicity

Wouldn't you rather buy based on a review with negatives as well as praise?

Basic logic tells us that negative opinions have a negative impact on our perceptions. If a man leaves a restaurant complaining about the service, he’s likely to drive other customers away. But this is not always the case: even negative reviews provide publicity and visibility, and a good can outshine the bad.

The Curious Case of the Envy 100

Last month I went shopping for a new computer printer after my trusty HP Photosmart give up the ghost. Being an iPad user, I decided to look for one that supported Apple’s AirPrint functionality. This left me looking once again at HP’s product line.

As I so often do, I spent some time familiarizing myself with the various products before heading out to the store. I quickly discovered that no one had yet analyzed only those printers that support AirPrint. Since I was interested in the topic, I decided to write up my experiences for my blog.

I was initially impressed by HP’s sleek and shiny Envy 100 all in one printer, but further investigation revealed the basic printer engine underneath. I concluded that the Envy 100 was not a good value for the money, and instead purchased the plain but functional Photosmart Premium FAX model instead.

But a funny thing happened since I posted my review. Of the tens of thousands of unique visitors my series on HP’s AirPrint compatible printers generated, dozens of people clicked through my links the Amazon to purchase one of the models listed. Surprisingly, HP’s Envy model is the top seller among those who purchased based on my series of reviews.

Credible Means Fair and Balanced

Why would someone rush out to buy after reading a negative review? Perhaps the answer lies in the review itself. Although I concluded that the Envy 100 was not a good value, I did praise its good looks and features. I also pointed out that fashion-conscious Apple buyers (who incidentally make up a large portion of my audience) would find the printer appealing. In short, my review was fair rather than negative.

I have found that fairness, mixing the good with the bad, yields much better results than effusive praise. This is especially true on the Internet, where credibility matters above all else. Clearly, my readers felt that my review was a fair depiction of the product and made their buying decision based on this unbiased view.

Lesson Learned

Corporate marketers can learn a lot from this experience. Although it can be upsetting to see the negative aspects of your product called out in public, it may not be the catastrophe you anticipate. It is difficult to let go and allow social media and unbiased reviews to stand, but they are your best advocate. Don’t get too upset when the commentary goes negative, as long as the overall tone is fair.

You might also want to read 4 Steps To Respond When Social Media Goes Negative and Always Punch Above Your Weight

Related Posts:

  • How to Build Trust at Work (With Anyone!)
  • Marketing Your Offerings (and Yourself!) in 2021
  • Work With Sales to Reach Marketing Goals
  • What Type of Marketing Videos Should I Create? Part One
  • LinkedIn Management in 30 Minutes Per Week

Share this:

  • Email
  • Print
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter

Filed Under: Commentary Tagged With: blogging, fairness, HP, marketing, negative, Photosmart, reviews

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Amrita Chandra says

    February 1, 2011 at 5:59 pm

    Great post, Steve.

  2. Jeff Darcy says

    February 1, 2011 at 6:17 pm

    Sadly, advice like yours is more likely to encourage faux fairness than actual fairness. I think many marketers do realize that people see through fulsome praise, so the smarter ones will throw in a few “negatives” that won’t stop anybody from buying but do quell the impulse to skip the whole review. “The noise from the rapidly printing pages could frighten small animals.” “The images seemed too sharp, lacking the personal warmth of older printers.” I could probably find more subtle/realistic examples from real product reviews, but you get the idea. People who read the negative reviews as a reality check – and I admit I’m one of these – need to be as alert for this kind of manipulation as those who read only the positive reviews.

    • sfoskett says

      February 1, 2011 at 6:25 pm

      It is difficult to separate credible and independent voices from the astroturf of marketers. This is a sad fact of the Internet, isn’t it?

      I was hoping to reassure vendors that I will tell it like it is and that they shouldn’t flip out at me (like one recently did) just because I didn’t like their product. It all comes around, and sometimes it comes around in surprising ways. Thus this weird example!

      Ever see Arrested Development? They were all thrilled to be upgraded to “don’t buy” by the Mad Money guy. Hah!

      Good points as always, Jeff.

Trackbacks

  1. Tweets that mention The Power of Negative Publicity « Foskett Services -- Topsy.com says:
    February 1, 2011 at 1:21 pm

    […] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Stephen Foskett, Marcus Burton. Marcus Burton said: RT @SFoskett: [Shared] The Power of Negative Publicity « Foskett Services http://bit.ly/hEiyes –> Excellent point about unbiased reviews! […]

  2. Back From the Pile: Interesting Links, February 4, 2011 – Stephen Foskett, Pack Rat says:
    February 7, 2011 at 10:26 am

    […] I was amazed to see the result of my HP Photosmart printer series: The Power of Negative Publicity […]

  3. Nuance Responds to My Dragon Dictate Concerns – Stephen Foskett, Pack Rat says:
    June 3, 2011 at 10:59 am

    […] all. All too often, companies don’t have this kind of proactive, honest response to feedback, especially when it’s negative. But you’re doing the right thing by responding like this! Hi […]

Primary Sidebar

  • Home
  • About
  • Clients
  • Services
    • Ambassador Programs
    • Event Management
    • Event Speakers
    • Tech Field Day
    • Video Production
    • Writing
  • News
  • Commentary

Footer

News

Storage Field Day Exclusive Comes to Pure Accelerate 2017

Tech Field Day Viewership Rockets Forward in 2015

Stephen Foskett Delivers Keynote at DeltaWare Data Solutions Emerging Technology Summit

More News...

Commentary

What Type of Marketing Videos Should I Create? Part One

How to Build Trust at Work (With Anyone!)

LinkedIn Management in 30 Minutes Per Week

More Commentary...

Subscribe Via Email

Contact Us

Contact Us Today

Copyright © 2023 · Executive Pro on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in